SUIYHA
Scott Parker
you've just listed some of the most intelligent players who have played full back in the past 20 years there. And lennon is smaller than all of them. and a worse footballer with less footballing intelligence.
if you think a player like phillip lahm, who is currently captaining possibly the best club side of the last 10 years, whilst playing from defensive midfield, is an apt comparison for aaron lennon, then fair play to you. why not try lennon in goal - he'd be quick coming off his line.
He's only an inch shorter than Roberto Carlos. My point is that you don't need to be a big six footer to play in defence at full-back. More important is pace, positional ability, first touch, tackling ability, good movement and anticipation. It's not about saying Lennon is better than any of these players, it's about saying that his lack of size shouldn't count against him in this instance.
Is this not what Lennon would be doing too?
Yes Lennon has put in some good defensive shifts in the past but tracking runs as a midfielder is not the same as playing as a FB. The back line should play as a unit (yeah yeah we're ****e at that) and this is something that should be instinctive to a FB who has trained there over an extended period. There is way more to it than just being able to run back fast. Offside game, covering the CB's, headed clearances. Nah.
I know it is en vogue to Lennon bash at the moment but it's my own opinion that his defensive qualities are well overstated. Even in that Liverpool match there were numerous occasions where he lost the ball or misplaced a pass, and he just stood there with a scowl on his face for 3-4 seconds before walking back towards his own half. Barca employ the five second rule to regain possession when they loose it. It's in those initial few seconds when you loose the ball is best time to win it back. Being a Barca disciple you can see Rodger's Liverpool use this to great effect.
Lennon's effectiveness should be going forward, playing to his strengths, but he's lost the spark for whatever reason. I wouldn't put him anywhere on the pitch at the moment and least of all in the defence. That's ****ed enough as it is.
Sometimes though - players are able to re-adapt their natural game to fit in at full-back. Zokora had been a crap CM for years for us, then Harry put him at RB to everyone's horror, but I've got vivid memories of him dingdonging on Ronaldo and keeping a clean sheet against Man Utd. He kept his place at RB for several months IIRC. Flamini was a DM until Wenger decided to play him at LB during Arsenal's run to the CL final in 2006. The positional stuff is not easy, but it can be trained and practiced just like anything else. It's not like our current full-backs are excelling at it. It's much easier to learn how to play an offside trap than it is to learn how to run faster or control a football better. I think Lennon is more intelligent than some of you give him credit for - remember the way Corluka, an intelligent full-back, used to slip him in behind with those diagonal balls. Nobody in our team picks him out like that anymore...
I really don't see what Naughton is offering that makes this such a bad idea. He should not be at Spurs next season, so why not see if we've got an existing player than can play in this position as opposed to signing another new RB.