• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Mauricio Pochettino

Is it any 'poorer' than ours at the start of the 2015-15 season though?

1794836763034.png

Yes, they don't run, have legs or speed.

Really don't understand why this is never brought up, their first choice CB's are 44th & 73rd for speed amongst PL defenders.

On top of that, Poch style training mid season for a squad that has quite a few injury prone players?
 
View attachment 23644

Yes, they don't run, have legs or speed.

Really don't understand why this is never brought up, their first choice CB's are 44th & 73rd for speed amongst PL defenders.

On top of that, Poch style training mid season for a squad that has quite a few injury prone players?

It's one thing talking about athleticism, but i was talking about player quality overall. Remember, however one wants to look at the circumstances etc, it is a squad that finished 3rd last season. Was our squad at the start of the 2014/15 season (which had previously finished 6th) really much better?
 
It's one thing talking about athleticism, but i was talking about player quality overall. Remember, however one wants to look at the circumstances etc, it is a squad that finished 3rd last season. Was our squad at the start of the 2014/15 season (which had previously finished 6th) really much better?

technical quality? maybe not

But Poch's style and current PL meta is all about athleticism .. it's why I didn't think Howe made sense for them either
 
technical quality? maybe not

But Poch's style and current PL meta is all about athleticism .. it's why I didn't think Howe made sense for them either

I see what you mean re style. But that's only an issue if it's felt that more than, say, 70% of the squad wouldn't even be capable of more athleticism.
I think the squad are (generally) very capable and it was just Carrick not putting a lot of faith/stock into it
 
Much poorer
They have 2/3 top players and a LOT of brick
We had players who were won the upwards curve whereas most of there’s are on the reverse

How can they really be seen as 'much poorer' when they finished 3rd last season, whilst ours hadn't managed 4th since Redknapp?
I agree with the upwards curve but it still needed Poch to work his magic to get us purring. I don't see why he can't do the same with their team.

I bet if we were to compare individual players of theirs now to ours then, there really wouldn't be much difference. In fact in many key positions i'd expect them to compare better tbh, we forget how mediocre we viewed our squad after Bale had been replaced by the fab 7 and by the time Sherwood had been sacked...
 
How can they really be seen as 'much poorer' when they finished 3rd last season, whilst ours hadn't managed 4th since Redknapp?
I agree with the upwards curve but it still needed Poch to work his magic to get us purring. I don't see why he can't do the same with their team.

I bet if we were to compare individual players of theirs now to ours then, there really wouldn't be much difference. In fact in many key positions i'd expect them to compare better tbh, we forget how mediocre we viewed our squad after Bale had been replaced by the fab 7 and by the time Sherwood had been sacked...
Different league
Different season
They have NO defenders or midfielders that would have made our side back then IMO
 
Different league
Different season
They have NO defenders or midfielders that would have made our side back then IMO

Really?
You don't think the current levels of De Light or Yorro would have been more useful than the likes of Fazio or competed with Kaboul?
You don't think Fernandes, Mainoo, Mount or even the older-version of Teliemens would have been useful or good rotation options vs Capoue, Mason, Bentaleb?
 
Really?
You don't think the current levels of De Light or Yorro would have been more useful than the likes of Fazio or competed with Kaboul?
You don't think Fernandes, Mainoo, Mount or even the older-version of Teliemens would have been useful or good rotation options vs Capoue, Mason, Bentaleb?

I agree with you, let’s also remember Stambouli, Soldado, Andros…I think the idea that United’s squad is terrible is overblown.

One thing that is consistent with Poch is that consistent results are not immediate. He takes time to establish his culture and standards, and then the results follow. So my concern with him is how much time he gets at United. On the flip side, they’ve been so bad that they can’t be worse, and any small boost is going to be additive. Maybe it’s the perfect time for him to be making changes.

In terms of player quality though, I think the disparity is overblown. I find the idea that he inherited incredible players to be weirdly pervasive in a lot of what I read about him. And I also think United’s players are suffering from a crisis of confidence like ours were last season. Maguire has already talked about feeling like the ‘crisis is descending’ when something goes against them. They are also not as bad as is being made out, and there’s plenty there Poch can get a tune out of.
 
Really?
You don't think the current levels of De Light or Yorro would have been more useful than the likes of Fazio or competed with Kaboul?
You don't think Fernandes, Mainoo, Mount or even the older-version of Teliemens would have been useful or good rotation options vs Capoue, Mason, Bentaleb?
No
I think they are flaky and actually quite brick
It’s why they have reverted back to their mean this season as soon as extra games have been added
Dont forget the majority of this united side finished one place above anges side who as we know were resting in games
I think it’s the age of old thing if under rating and over rating players at various points
De ligt doesn’t even start for united now so your really talking about Martinez and slab head
Mainoo is just like Tielemans in that he is very hot and cold
Mount is gash…. Doesnt really start for united either
 
I agree with you, let’s also remember Stambouli, Soldado, Andros…I think the idea that United’s squad is terrible is overblown.

One thing that is consistent with Poch is that consistent results are not immediate. He takes time to establish his culture and standards, and then the results follow. So my concern with him is how much time he gets at United. On the flip side, they’ve been so bad that they can’t be worse, and any small boost is going to be additive. Maybe it’s the perfect time for him to be making changes.

In terms of player quality though, I think the disparity is overblown. I find the idea that he inherited incredible players to be weirdly pervasive in a lot of what I read about him. And I also think United’s players are suffering from a crisis of confidence like ours were last season. Maguire has already talked about feeling like the ‘crisis is descending’ when something goes against them. They are also not as bad as is being made out, and there’s plenty there Poch can get a tune out of.
Uniteds squad is awful
One CF and a player in zirkee they want rid because they realised he can’t really keep up with the pace of the prem
And aging defence with Yoro and the ex arsenal kid to help keep the age down
A miss mash of centre midfielders who have no cohesive style between them
An average keeper who doesn’t excel at anything statistically or to the eye
MBuemo and Cunha are quality players and Fernandes can be …
As I said above this is the core of the team that just finished above anges side when he got fired
 
Uniteds squad is awful
One CF and a player in zirkee they want rid because they realised he can’t really keep up with the pace of the prem
And aging defence with Yoro and the ex arsenal kid to help keep the age down
A miss mash of centre midfielders who have no cohesive style between them
An average keeper who doesn’t excel at anything statistically or to the eye
MBuemo and Cunha are quality players and Fernandes can be …
As I said above this is the core of the team that just finished above anges side when he got fired

My point is how it compared to the squad Poch took over in summer 2014.

I bet if you listed both United's squad now and Poch's first Spurs squad after the close of the summer 2014 window (when we had the likes of Fazio, Stambouli etc), i don't think you'll be seeing much difference overall in quality.
 
I agree with you, let’s also remember Stambouli, Soldado, Andros…I think the idea that United’s squad is terrible is overblown.

One thing that is consistent with Poch is that consistent results are not immediate. He takes time to establish his culture and standards, and then the results follow. So my concern with him is how much time he gets at United. On the flip side, they’ve been so bad that they can’t be worse, and any small boost is going to be additive. Maybe it’s the perfect time for him to be making changes.

In terms of player quality though, I think the disparity is overblown. I find the idea that he inherited incredible players to be weirdly pervasive in a lot of what I read about him. And I also think United’s players are suffering from a crisis of confidence like ours were last season. Maguire has already talked about feeling like the ‘crisis is descending’ when something goes against them. They are also not as bad as is being made out, and there’s plenty there Poch can get a tune out of.
Agree with pretty much all of this. However, I do believe that United and their fan base are one of the more patient clubs in the league. While it takes time for Poch to embed his expectations, style and culture it usually starts to happen after months rather than years. He'll get that time.

Poch plays good football, gives youth a chance and can build a football club. He's perfect for Man U IMO. The danger for him is that the toxicity around the place and the rubbish leadership above him mean it's impossible for one man to make a difference.
 
I agree with you, let’s also remember Stambouli, Soldado, Andros…I think the idea that United’s squad is terrible is overblown.

One thing that is consistent with Poch is that consistent results are not immediate. He takes time to establish his culture and standards, and then the results follow. So my concern with him is how much time he gets at United. On the flip side, they’ve been so bad that they can’t be worse, and any small boost is going to be additive. Maybe it’s the perfect time for him to be making changes.

In terms of player quality though, I think the disparity is overblown. I find the idea that he inherited incredible players to be weirdly pervasive in a lot of what I read about him. And I also think United’s players are suffering from a crisis of confidence like ours were last season. Maguire has already talked about feeling like the ‘crisis is descending’ when something goes against them. They are also not as bad as is being made out, and there’s plenty there Poch can get a tune out of.

He has this season and the pre-season to get ready for next year. Is that enough time to establish his culture and standards, or at least make strong progress in that direction? All he has to do this season is avoid relegation, which shouldn't be too difficult. Assuming he can get a new-manager bounce and get out of immediate danger, he should be able to concentrate on changes for next season rather than winning as many games as possible.
 
Back