• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Circus ManUnitus - Nobody's At The Wheel

Agreed.

I think the stuff about stars needing to align is absolutely true. It’s true of every manager, frankly I don’t understand why it’s so hard for football owners to understand this.

He was lucky to find a club in us who realised that it wasn’t just about signing good players anymore, we needed to try something else, have something to believe in and get behind. And he is one of the rare managers who can actually build a long term culture like that. He did an amazing job.

But then you get into; coaching, development, pre game and half time motivation, standards, tactics, adaptability, in game management, and he was excellent there too.

He squeezed a Champions League final out of a team that really had no business being there. And then it started to fall when he couldn’t refresh the squad. But the level of his achievement with us makes it baffling why he isn’t considered extremely special, and frankly the scepticism of the United fans baffles me, ‘is he a good manager???’ Like wtf guys what do you want!

He's the best manager they can attract, and that says more about them than it does about him.
 
Oh I dont agree with Poch inheriting quality either. He made a lot of the players better, young ones and also those already established. I do believe some coaches are just a better fit at a club than others and timing of managing a club can be important too and why many good managers fail at clubs.

FWIW I think he will do very well at Man U, they are too much of a giant not to get back to where they once were and I could envisage Poch being the guy to get them there....

It will take them a while. The whole squad needs turning over, bar Mainoo. Unlike Chelsea, he doesn't have the young pool to pull on. But he'll get them back to the top in 2-3 years.
 
I'd imagine champions league qualification next season would be a minimum expectation. Just signs of improvement this season should be sufficient to stay on. That said, they probably expect some Europe qualification this year, as they're only 7 points off 7th and 8 off 5th. Form like Carrick's last year would probably do it.
 
I'm pleased for Poch. If he makes it through the first 18 months then he'll be an awesome manager for them long term.

It will be incredibly tough during that period though.
 
I'd imagine champions league qualification next season would be a minimum expectation. Just signs of improvement this season should be sufficient to stay on. That said, they probably expect some Europe qualification this year, as they're only 7 points off 7th and 8 off 5th. Form like Carrick's last year would probably do it.

That's what Carrick got them, didn't do him much good. They need 6 players with at least 2 being the best in their position. I believe there is a dearth of the type of players they need, systems are taking out the mavericks which United have always been able to get. Like us they are not as attractive opinion for top players as they were and will have to pay top prices and wages whilst trying to unload big earners.
I think his first priority will be to sign Kane.
 
That's what Carrick got them, didn't do him much good. They need 6 players with at least 2 being the best in their position. I believe there is a dearth of the type of players they need, systems are taking out the mavericks which United have always been able to get. Like us they are not as attractive opinion for top players as they were and will have to pay top prices and wages whilst trying to unload big earners.
I think his first priority will be to sign Kane.
Kane? Apart from anything else, he has just signed on for two more years in Germany.
 
If they'd got Poch in the summer, Kane might have been a possibility. Kane would probably like to work with him again. However, he seems happy in Germany and has signed a new contract. I can't seem him giving a tearful news conference announcing he could resist going to Manchester.

That's what Carrick got them, didn't do him much good. They need 6 players with at least 2 being the best in their position. I believe there is a dearth of the type of players they need, systems are taking out the mavericks which United have always been able to get. Like us they are not as attractive opinion for top players as they were and will have to pay top prices and wages whilst trying to unload big earners.
I think his first priority will be to sign Kane.

Yes, my comment was somewhat contradictory. Probably I should have said CL qualification next season should be the minimum expectation. But that requires them to be realistic, which is rather defying the nature of the United regime. They have too many people in high positions needing someone to fire for their own failures.

Possibly the worst thing for Poch would be a good start and then poorer form towards end of the season as fatigue kicks in. A poor start with slow progress to mid-table might be safer for this season.
 
Also gave an interview this saying week that he will do two more seasons after this one at Bayern before moving back to the PL. (He said that he feels he has a number of years left at the top level).

Yes, but Kane isn't going to walk into a rebuild, and in that interview, he said "it's possible, not guaranteed". My perspective is a side would have to be in a pretty good position to tempt him, he needs a side that will have a dominant couple of seasons. United hasn't been that side in more than a decade, City is out, he won't do the Scum, Chelsea is flakey as fudge .. doesn't leave him a lot of options.

Aside from anything else, United don’t have the money, or transfer/squad spending headroom, to buy Kane out of a newly-signed two year contract.

Isn't stopping the deluded United biased media, apparently, they will just go buy Paz for their midfield, insert whatever top player that will absolutely not go to United is suddenly going to be "obviously a United target"
 
Back