Over rated more like. When has he delivered at all this season. The stats dont lie like some on here pretend. Sorry to disullusion you guys, but he isnt the best thing since sliced bread. He doesnt even do what it says on the tin.
That's an extremely disappointing view. It's surprising to see him so unappreciated that someone can ask when he's delivered at all this season.
Over-rated by us, perhaps. But we'll over-rate every single Spurs player given the chance. I think if everyone on this board made a Premier League XI, there would be far more Spurs players in it than if random football fans made Premier League XIs, but that's the same with all supporters. When you consider how highly people talk of Walker, Kaboul, King, BAE, Bale and plenty of others, I don't think Modric is over-rated out of proportion to everyone else.
That said, when things were going well, we might have over-rated everyone a little bit more than we would now, although I think there's a chance of people undervaluing some of the squad now too. I feel your comment is one of those because it is so extreme. Over the entire season you can find his best performances, so it's really not rational to begin a debate by letting someone go through 40+ games to find a game that you won't be able to deny Modric played well in, especially when it'd be easy to pick a game Modric scored a goal in, which isn't even the primary or secondary reason he's picked.
The stats dont lie like some on here pretend.
Ok. League Stats.
Played: 31
Assists: 4
Key Passes: 83 (2.7 average)
Passes 2111 (68.1)
Completed Passes 1854 (87.8%)
Long Passes: 232/277
Through Passes: 15/33
-------
Paul Scholes:
Played 10. (So remember Modric has played triple the games, it won't change the averages but it won't make Modric look like Xavi.)
Assists: 0
Key Passes: 15 (1.2 average.)
Passes: 880 (67.7 average.)
Completed: 814 (92.5%)
Long Passes: 129/149
Through Balls: 2/4
"Of PL players to have made 150+ passes this season, Scholes makes the highest proportion of those passes sideways (70%)"
Source:
http://www.whoscored.com/Players/20874/Show/Luka-Modric and
http://www.whoscored.com/Players/11/Show/Paul-Scholes
That quote is from the site's twitter, if you want more stats, feel free. I got tired of posting them... Modric makes twice the interceptions and Scholes gives away 250% as many fouls, but he attempts .5 more tackles, etc.
I can turn on any TV/radio station talking about football and all I hear is people saying Scholes is the reason that United are going to win the title this year, I watched MotD2 today and saw some analysis on him as he was man of the match yet again. You get stats like "started 10, won 10" told to you all the time as well as reminders that the he wasn't even on the Bench for the Wigan game and so on.
Man United are the highest scoring team in the league, I think. Paul Scholes has 0 assists in his 10 games, Modric has 4 in his 31. But for Modric to have well over double the average key passes has got to highlight how valuable he is? Modric is less likely to do a Hudds type pass, which Scholes does often, but so many stats points to Modric does more than enough to deserve better than the kind of comments you give him.
He is usually one of the contenders for MotM for us, whether we win, lose or draw.
--------------------
He doesnt even do what it says on the tin
Yes, he does.
The sheer volume of passes says that he does. The key passes says he does.
What is it you want him to do?
Xavi, Scholes, Xabi Alonso all do varying degrees of what Modric does, I can write a bigger list if you need one but what do they do that Modric doesn't do? Xavi is the best player in the entire world at what he does, at his position... It is very likely that he is the best midfielder in the world. Xabi Alonso is another of the best players in the world. I'm not saying Modric is as good as those two, but that's his position. We're not as good as Barca or Real Madrid.
Xabi Alonso has played 31 league games (the same as Modric), he has fewer key passes, he only has a 0.2% better pass completion rate. He has double the assists but fudge me, he has the top La Liga goalscorers to pass to, including Ronaldo, Benzema and Higuin... (Also including Kaka, Ozil, Di Maria and a whole host of others. Modric has Ade, Bale, VDV and Lennon to pass to.)
Defensively, Xabi Alonso is better, making almost double the amount of tackles, about the same amount of interceptions, about three times as many fouls and getting dribbled around almost twice as often.
http://www.whoscored.com/Players/4961/Show/Xabi-Alonso
Now to Xavi:
Played 24(4) (An awkward number to compare to Modric's 31.)
Assists 6. (Again, Xavi can pass to Barca players including Messi. Barca score far more goals than we do.)
Average Key Passes: 2.1 (Lower than Modric.)
92.4% Pass Completion with 97 passes per game average.
Barca average 70% possession in all games.
I think Modric helps us average 57% possession at WHL.
The comparison is ridiculous unless you compare players like Bale with players like Ronaldo, but I just compared Modric to the absolute best in the world in his position and he came out well. What the fudge else does it say on the tin?
The goal scoring stats are on a different page, but I know it's Xavi's best goalscoring season, so I'm just going to state in his defence that he's scored 10 goals this season.
http://www.whoscored.com/Players/2302/Show/Xavi
Last year, he played 31 La Liga games and scored 3 goals, that's the same amount Modric has now (31 games also)... The year before that, Xavi scored 3 La Liga goals (34 games that time), in some seasons he scored more, in some he didn't score at all.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xavi#Career_statistics
If you want Xavi + Lampard + Lucas + Zidane, you're going to be disappointed... He's a Spurs player, I don't know what you expect? If you want the best players in the world to play for Spurs, we need to be able to offer them something... Even Emirates Marketing Project haven't been able to buy more than a sprinkling of world class talent, most of the time they have a left back that can't defend (nowhere near world class), either Barry or Milner in midfield (nowhere near world class), Lescott or Toure in defence... They pay insane money to buy their players and insane money on wages... The only two teams that are world class all the way through are Real Madrid and Barca.
So who is an upgrade to Modric that we can replace him with? Ignoring him being one of our 2 best players and the difficulties even keeping him...
Also, Xavi is 32, Scholes is 37, Xabi Alonso is 30... Modric is 26.
When Liverpool let Xabi Alonso go, they went to brick, that's how good Xabi Alonso is.
------------------
I have no idea how long ago you stopped reading, but it was extremely unfair to ask if he has delivered at any point during the season.