jts1882
Dean Richards
I think the idea of having a squad where players can be interchanged seamlessly has two problems. One, it isn't really designed for a plan B (just a fresher version of plan A) and, two, it requires too many players for everyone to get enough games. It also tends to drift to an A team and B team.
I think what you really want is several variants on the main theme, where some players come in to slightly change the way we are playing (more defensive, better crossers, more pace, etc). This way you rotate according to the opposition you face and then have natural substitutes to fit a plan B during a game. This way you end up with 14-15 players where it is not entirely certain who are the first XI.
We are closest to doing this in the three-quarter line. While Lamela, Alli and Eriksen are the first choice, Eriksen seamlessly replace Alli in the centre and Son and Chadli can change the balance of the trio. Dembele can also move forward and provide a different balance.
We have good balance in the defense too, although the way it seems to be Rose and Walker or Trippier and Davies reinforces the pecking order. It might suit the squad game better if Trippier was preferred in some games and Davies in others, making the choice on the opponent.
P.S. Wasn't Alli playing alongside Dier in the deeper role early in the season. Perhaps that could have been an alternative for Dembele late in the season too (although obviously not Sunday).
I think what you really want is several variants on the main theme, where some players come in to slightly change the way we are playing (more defensive, better crossers, more pace, etc). This way you rotate according to the opposition you face and then have natural substitutes to fit a plan B during a game. This way you end up with 14-15 players where it is not entirely certain who are the first XI.
We are closest to doing this in the three-quarter line. While Lamela, Alli and Eriksen are the first choice, Eriksen seamlessly replace Alli in the centre and Son and Chadli can change the balance of the trio. Dembele can also move forward and provide a different balance.
We have good balance in the defense too, although the way it seems to be Rose and Walker or Trippier and Davies reinforces the pecking order. It might suit the squad game better if Trippier was preferred in some games and Davies in others, making the choice on the opponent.
P.S. Wasn't Alli playing alongside Dier in the deeper role early in the season. Perhaps that could have been an alternative for Dembele late in the season too (although obviously not Sunday).