It is close one for me. Definitely needs to be playmaker. And Hoddle is the obvious choice. But I'm not sure how he would fare in the modern, very physical, crowded three man midfield era, with 4-2-3-1 so common. I'd like to think he would still find the space and time to showcase his sublime skill on the ball. And if he did, he would be the player to have.
But I'm going to go with Gazza, because he combined a physical robust energetic approach to the game, with good mobility, great passing skills, dribbling, shooting, goal scoring, set pieces - apart from some wild tackling (and setting aside the personal stuff) Gazza really did have it all.