milo
Jack L. Jones
Maybe. I can be pretty hyperbolic in my expression, but I only go on what I see and the genuine opinions I have. At least I express why I think the way I do. I used to say the same about Harry Kane, but he's obviously incredible. Townsend, Mason and Carroll have never impressed me. Moments here and there. Rose was fantastic last season (I thought he was awful before that). I genuinely would love Mason and Carroll to turn out to be incredible players, but they haven't shown even glimpses that they can reach those heights.
I think that you are right that going overboard in your criticism can grate on other posters and can make it look like you will single out a player for criticism regardless of their performance.