Really, I thought Sanchez booking was a joke, especially considering how 'physical' they were. Replay showed he had a clear view of the pen yet said the defender player the ball when it was yards away.You obviously didn't watch the Barca game. Nothing wrong with the ref today!
Didn't look like a pen, and the booking is nothing to moan about. So that's maybe 1 questionable situation out of maybe 200, meaning he got 0,5% of them wrong (if it was a pen, which it wasn't. Even Rose didn't make any fuzz about it).Really, I thought Sanchez booking was a joke, especially considering how 'physical' they were. Replay showed he had a clear view of the pen yet said the defender player the ball when it was yards away.
Terrible display.
What didn't look like a pen about it? The ref even saw he took Rose out because he was signalling that the defender got the ball first. Problem is, the ball was never within a yard of the defender - clearly a pen.Didn't look like a pen, and the booking is nothing to moan about. So that's maybe 1 questionable situation out of maybe 200, meaning he got 0,5% of them wrong (if it was a pen, which it wasn't. Even Rose didn't make any fuzz about it).
Well seems there's only two people who think it wasnt a pen, you and the ref.Didn't look like a pen, and the booking is nothing to moan about. So that's maybe 1 questionable situation out of maybe 200, meaning he got 0,5% of them wrong (if it was a pen, which it wasn't. Even Rose didn't make any fuzz about it).
Glad to see the outbreak of common sense about the match today. Function over form. Love to watch Moura in jink and wriggle his way through traffic. Really growing into the team.
Sean Morrison looked a very decent player today. When Cardiff go down, could easily see him fitting into a better PL side.
The ‘penalty’ incident happened pretty much in front of where I was standing. I half heartedly called for it but wasn’t really. convinced. No one around me seemed particularly outraged that it wasn’t given.
I haven’t seen a replay though yet.
As to the game : we looked very laboured but did nonetheless create enough chances to have won comfortably. We must get better at converting those chances in these games.
Sissoko had a decent game. Moura looked good. Kane battled as Kane does. Winks looks like his confidence is returning. I had forgotten how pacey he can be. Lamela livened things up when he came on.
I think there were some tired legs out there after Wednesday. So, 3 points and a clean sheet is what the table will show, regardless of performance.
I am however looking forward to the game where we do turn it on.
Dean did NOT have a bad game. End of! Just because there were two(!!) decisions you don't agree with, that doesn't make it a bad game for the ref! Honestly, there were plenty of other things to worry about!Well seems there's only two people who think it wasnt a pen, you and the ref.
Thats two I've quoted but there was a lot more so your arithmetic is questionable at best.
Kane got another battering today. It’s almost as if he’s playing in a game from the late 80’s/early 90’s the way he gets smashed every time he’s on the ball while refs give fouls and yellows for much less on other players. At least it seems that way. In so many league games the CB’s have fouled him so many times before the get a card (if they even do).The ‘penalty’ incident happened pretty much in front of where I was standing. I half heartedly called for it but wasn’t really. convinced. No one around me seemed particularly outraged that it wasn’t given.
I haven’t seen a replay though yet.
As to the game : we looked very laboured but did nonetheless create enough chances to have won comfortably. We must get better at converting those chances in these games.
Sissoko had a decent game. Moura looked good. Kane battled as Kane does. Winks looks like his confidence is returning. I had forgotten how pacey he can be. Lamela livened things up when he came on.
I think there were some tired legs out there after Wednesday. So, 3 points and a clean sheet is what the table will show, regardless of performance.
I am however looking forward to the game where we do turn it on.
And given his previous goal celebrations when we’ve scored he’s got to be careful. I’m sure if Cardiff had equalized he would have done his bit.Dean did NOT have a bad game. End of! Just because there were two(!!) decisions you don't agree with, that doesn't make it a bad game for the ref! Honestly, there were plenty of other things to worry about!
Not saying that there isn't a lot to be worried about from our point of view, but that doesn't change the fact that the ref imv had a terrible game.Dean did NOT have a bad game. End of! Just because there were two(!!) decisions you don't agree with, that doesn't make it a bad game for the ref! Honestly, there were plenty of other things to worry about!
You're pretty alone with that view.Not saying that there isn't a lot to be worried about from our point of view, but that doesn't change the fact that the ref imv had a terrible game.
You're pretty alone with that view.
Called out by who? Pundits? They are always correct and know the rules... Sure.Don't think I am as he was getting called out for the red card and no pen.
I would agree with no pen if he said rose went to easy, but to say that it was because the defender p,aged the ball is a shocking decision.
He gave same totally bizarre decisions, Sanchez booking, red card, giving a foul against dier when he was barged, not giving a foul against trippier on I think it was hoillet.
He stands up to the buffeting which is admirable, but he'll get nothing for it. Being honest is not a trait rewarded in the modern game.Kane got another battering today. It’s almost as if he’s playing in a game from the late 80’s/early 90’s the way he gets smashed every time he’s on the ball while refs give fouls and yellows for much less on other players. At least it seems that way. In so many league games the CB’s have fouled him so many times before the get a card (if they even do).
Def red, ridiculous challenge, the ball was not within 5 meters of him and he tackled in 90 degrees the opposite direction of the way it was travelling at knee height!!!!The red looked stonewall to me, cynical and knee high.