Manchester United nullified Gareth Bale but forgot about Aaron Lennon
Phil Jones was selected to help contain the Welshman but space opened up on the other flank
Michael Cox
The Guardian, Sunday 20 January 2013 20.49 GMT
Tottenham's Aaron Lennon, left, caused plenty of problems for the Manchester United defender Patrice Evra at White Hart Lane. Photograph: Ian Kington/AFP/Getty Images
To understand Manchester United's cautious strategy at White Hart Lane, think back to their 3-2 defeat by Tottenham at Old Trafford in September. Then Spurs had terrorised the United back four with powerful dribbles from deep positions – Mousa Dembélé provided bursts from central midfield, Jan Vertonghen motored forward to open the scoring but Gareth Bale was inevitably the principal threat with surging runs on the ball. Therefore United's entire approach was intended to prevent André Villas-Boas's side attacking quickly into space.
Whereas Sir Alex Ferguson ordered high pressing against Liverpool last weekend, here they stood off, defending deep and ensuring there was little space in behind their back four. There was little space in front of it either, at least towards Bale's flank. His dribbling ability was the reason for Phil Jones's surprise involvementJones sat patiently in front of the defence, right-of-centre, always in a position to help Rafael da Silva deal with Bale. The Brazilian has fared well in one-against-one situations against the Tottenham winger over the past couple of seasons – Bale's goal at Old Trafford earlier in the season coming when the Welshman charged directly at the centre of United's defence.
Jones's positioning here prevented that possibility, as he subtly ushered Bale down the flank, where Da Silva's good defending meant it took Bale an hour to deliver a decent cross. As Bale became frustrated at his lack of space, he wandered into the centre of the pitch, away from both Jones and Da Silva.
That, in itself, was evidence that United's approach had been successful: Bale's experiments with a central role last season came after he complained about being double-marked, especially in home games, but he does not possess the all-round ability to thrive from a starting position in the centre, particularly as United remained so deep and compact.
United, however, by focusing on Bale, left gaps for others to exploit – Clint Dempsey, for example, was afforded too much space. There was one glaring example in the second half, when he wandered through the centre of the defence before being denied by David de Gea – Nemanja Vidic had moved across the pitch to track Bale's run, leaving a hole in the visitors' defence.
Phil Jones helped Rafael da Silva cope with Gareth Bale, but Tottenham often found gaps on the opposite flank. Graphic: Guardian
But the major beneficiary was Aaron Lennon, located on the opposite side to Bale. He dribbled at Patrice Evra, forcing the Frenchman into a couple of fouls that saw him booked before half-time, making him reluctant to challenge the Spurs winger after the break. Lennon could duck inside under no pressure and became increasingly threatening with his final ball – he set up a fine chance for Jermain Defoe who was thwarted only by Rio Ferdinand's last-ditch block, and was fittingly the man to tee up Dempsey's equaliser.
United were seconds from victory but had invited continual pressure without offering the counter-attacking threat that vindicated previous defensive-minded performances this season. With their focus on Bale, combined with Lennon's crucial contributions, United's lack of flying wingers was conspicuous: Ashley Young is injured, Nani is out of favour and the substitute Antonio Valencia has been poor in recent months. United only managed two attempts on target, their lowest figure of the season, primarily because they did not have men to carry the ball forward on the break to create chances – Ferguson needed the type of threat he had been so determined to prevent Tottenham showcasing.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/blog/2013/jan/20/tottenham-manchester-united-tactics?CMP=twt_gu