Match ratings Brighton and Hove Albion

[scaramanga]

Ade scored on sunday.....Soldado didn't score yesterday....

If Kane gets the nod then fair enough.

I thought it was all about assisting the assister?

 

[Spur of the moment]

Yes I can see the advantages for that purpose. I'm just pining for ye olde method. I preferred the opinions to the stats.

Me too. To be fair, graphing the ratings makes excellent sense but for some reason it seems to have had the effect of killing the comments. Hands up, as one who once frequently contributed both ratings and comments I find the separation of the ratings somehow saps the incentive to comment.

Don't ask me why, it just does. :-k

I fear this thread has lost much of its fizz.

 

[sc25]

Me too. To be fair, graphing the ratings makes excellent sense but for some reason it seems to have had the effect of killing the comments. Hands up, as one who once frequently contributed both ratings and comments I find the separation of the ratings somehow saps the incentive to comment.

Don't ask me why, it just does. :-k

I fear this thread has lost much of its fizz.

+1

 

[Ade's folks are ok really]

What the summary of responses does show though, is whilst everyone seems to pretty much agree on most of the player performances (all within one grade of each other, i.e 6/7/8 out of 10), the only two players that have a real spread of ratings is…probably unsurprisingly…Townsend and Paulinho!

#marmite

 

[Jordinho]

Giving Paulinho a 3 obviously has nothing to do with this game, but that's nothing new.

How Naughton could get anything less than a 7 is beyond me. Even 7 feels a bit harsh. He was up and down the pitch all the time, putting in crosses and had full control defensively. Yes, Brighton aren't all that, but how much more does he have to do?

Edit: I see some joker has been submitting 1s as well. #-o