• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Mathys Tel

I would ask everyone to watch a game of football with a pen and paoter and count how many decisions a referee needed to make in that game. Then, based on the laws, how many did they get right. Factor in that they should score zero for igoring or missing something that they should have acted on as well (based on laws only). Then ask youself how many of those were subjective if you were truly following the laws.

Your argument would be totally thrown out of the water. There are an incredibly few amount of subjective or contextual decisions if you apply the laws. Football has given this perception because referees stopped using the laws. So we find ourselves normalising to the nonsense.

As an example, last night Konsa was shielding the ball and taking it away from the Spanish guy and lost possession because that player kicked through his leg. The Spanish player didn't get the ball even though he may have been trying to do that. Additionally the on pitch referee could be forgiven for missing the leg being kicked versus the ball. After all, it's a fast game. However, then you bring the technology to the table and they get to see what we all saw. Now bear in mind one of ours was going to get sent off and one of their was about to get a penalty. THEY STILL GOT IT WRONG. There was absolutely nothing subjective at all about that incident. That is, if you are applying the laws of the game.

However, if you were to listen to commentary team, the pundits and probably the VAR team if you had access to their transcript, they're all making out it is subjective. Honestly, football has absolutely lost the plot.
Where is disagree with you is that the actual laws of football are very vague if you read them. Yes there is a ruling about kicking through a player but the subjective part is what is considering to be a kick through. That aspect is poorly defined imo and where the subjective part comes into play. It might appear obvious that it is a foul (I didn't watch the game or see the incident so I can't comment), but the actual laws of the game that define the entire referring approach are vague, possibly purposely so. So one referee may well feel that a situation like that is a foul whereas another might not. That's where the old "common sense" argument used to be made because there were some scenarios that felt fairly obvious but again the laws do not actually define what a foul is or isn't. They typically moreso state the punishment for a foul, rather than what actually constitutes the foul. So the refereeing approach is almost entirely subjective beyond the guidance that each referee is even at the begining of each season.

What would be useful is if the same guidance they are given and the examples they are shown as shared with the general public. At least the we would know what their framing is and it would help define some consistency but I'll always see it as subjective when even on here amongst a bunch of Tottenham fans all with the same ulterior motive we usually don't all argue on whether something was a foul of the severity of said foul.
 
Where is disagree with you is that the actual laws of football are very vague if you read them. Yes there is a ruling about kicking through a player but the subjective part is what is considering to be a kick through. That aspect is poorly defined imo and where the subjective part comes into play. It might appear obvious that it is a foul (I didn't watch the game or see the incident so I can't comment), but the actual laws of the game that define the entire referring approach are vague, possibly purposely so. So one referee may well feel that a situation like that is a foul whereas another might not. That's where the old "common sense" argument used to be made because there were some scenarios that felt fairly obvious but again the laws do not actually define what a foul is or isn't. They typically moreso state the punishment for a foul, rather than what actually constitutes the foul. So the refereeing approach is almost entirely subjective beyond the guidance that each referee is even at the begining of each season.

What would be useful is if the same guidance they are given and the examples they are shown as shared with the general public. At least the we would know what their framing is and it would help define some consistency but I'll always see it as subjective when even on here amongst a bunch of Tottenham fans all with the same ulterior motive we usually don't all argue on whether something was a foul of the severity of said foul.

So while I agree with the subjectiveness, it's also very easy to point out when the FA or whoever decide to act on something, e.g. timewasting on goal kicks or certain type of fouls, and usually it works for the first 2 months of a new season then regresses to same old brick. which to your point is about guidance and implementation
 
If the referees are supposed to be flawless should we not expect the same of players. Why are there even fouls if the players know how to make an acceptable challenge?

You’re asking way too much of a game if you expect referees to operate like they are compiling code. You have to remember most football is played in front of one man and his dog.
 
I was baffled, not only by the lack of at least a booking, but most of all by the comments made by both during and after the incident. No malice? Tel "too quick"? To me it looked like he jumped in, especially on the reverse angle replay. It wasn't a step, it was a headless and dangerous lunge, regardless of intent to hurt or not.

But for the umpteenth time, it's the inconsistency and uneven playing field that really does my head in, and it's seriously starting to affect my interest in football altogether.
There was no booking because the ref didn't see it. He only saw the foul that Bogle made with his right leg not the studs up stamp onto and above Tel's ankle from Bogle's left foot. It was interesting that the VAR explanation was words to the effect of "VAR agree with the referee's opinion that it wasn't a red card challenge". However, I'd love to see/hear the commentary to find out whether the ref was asked if he had seen the full studs contact on and above the ankle. If that question was asked and the ref says yes then the 'agreed with the referee' comment is fair enough (though still controversial).

It is blatantly obvious to me that the ref didn't see it though as no yellow card was awarded and there is no way that challenge isn't a yellow card challenge at the very least. That is why VAR failed in this instance, by 'agreeing with the ref' VAR has assumed that the ref saw the aspect of the challenge that perhaps made it a red (and IMO absolutely made it a red card) when the lack of yellow card from the ref should make it obvious to VAR that the ref has not seen the actual dangerous part of the foul.

VAR is basically not overturning the refs decision as a clear and obvious error while assuming that he saw something that the laws of probability indicate that he didn't see. If the ref had given the player a red card then there is no way VAR wouldn't overturned it and that is why the only outcome from that situation was for the ref to be sent to the screen to make his own mind up on whether or not it was a red card, and seeing as the same ref sent off Xavi Simmons after being sent to the monitor for a VAR review for almost identical contact (but in a less dangerous fashion with less force) the only outcome had the ref gone to the monitor was that Bogle would've been off and Leeds down to 10 men in the first half of the game with the score 0-0.
 
Last edited:
Football just needs to get beyond this stupid concept that the on-pitch referee needs to make every decision and be "in charge" of the game.

Last week at Twickenham one of the Aussies was given a yellow and sent to the sin bin for 10 mins. It them came up on screen that there was a further review to see if the yellow would be upgraded to a red. Eventually it came up on teh big screen that it was indeed only a yellow. For that entire review process the on pitch referee wasn't in the slightest involved. It was TMO doing the background work.

For me, this is how football should operate. The video ref should just be empowered to tell the on-pitch ref that his team has looked at the incident using the laws of the game and simply advise him of what decision he needs to make. It really isn't that difficult. TMO are obsessed with the laws. Nothing else.

As for your offside point, wouldn't it be great if one man is offside, entire team is offside. The art of offside is to get 4 defenders moving in synch to play the opposition offside. The determination that players can be on the pitch but not impacting play is ridiculous. A right back can be 50 yards away and playing everyone onslide but not impacting play and therefore gets penalised. A forward can be 5 yards away and therefore impacting play but is deemed as not offside and doesn't get penalised. The offside determinations just tells us that imbeciles run football.
Disagree with your last comment. If an attacking player slides in and crosses the ball into the box and his slide in results in him carrying on a few yards and a player in the middle heads the ball in then the player that crossed the ball would be would likely now be in an offside position. If a right back is 50 yards away then he is impacting play as the opposition will take their attacking line from that player.
 
Back