• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

The best album of the 90's - Blue Lines vs What's the Story Morning Glory

Which is the better album?


  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .

milo

Jack L. Jones
It's Massive Attack against Oasis in our thirteenth game of the first round. Two massive albums of the decade. Only one can go through.

Massive Attack - Blue Lines

220px-MassiveAttackBlueLines.jpg


Blue Lines is the debut album by English trip hop group Massive Attack, released on their Wild Bunch label through Virgin Recordson 8 April 1991.

"We worked on Blue Lines for about eight months, with breaks for Christmas and the World Cup," said 3D, "but we started out with a selection of ideas that were up to seven years old. Songs like 'Safe from Harm' and 'Lately' had been around for a while, from when we were The Wild Bunch, or from our time on the sound systems in Bristol. But the more we worked on them, the more we began to conceive new ideas too – like, 'Five Man Army' came together as a jam."[4]

Blue Lines is generally considered the first trip hop album,[5] although the term was not widely used before 1994.

The album reached No. 13 on the UK Albums Chart; sales were limited elsewhere. A fusion of electronic music, hip hop, dub, '70s souland reggae, it established Massive Attack as one of the most innovative British bands of the 1990s and the founder of trip hop'sBristol Sound.[6]

Music critic Simon Reynolds stated that the album also marked a change in electronic/dance music, "a shift toward a more interior,meditational sound. The songs on Blue Lines run at 'spliff' tempos – from a mellow, moonwalking 90 beats per minute ...down to a positively torpid 67 bpm."[7]

The group also drew inspiration from concept albums in various genres by artists such as Pink Floyd, Public Image Ltd., Billy Cobham,Herbie Hanrooster and Isaac Hayes.[7]

Vs

220px-Oasis_-_%28What%27s_The_Story%29_Morning_Glory_album_cover.jpg

(What's the Story) Morning Glory? is the second studio album by the English rock band Oasis, released on 2 October 1995 byCreation Records. It was produced by Owen Morris and the group's guitarist Noel Gallagher. The structure and arrangement style of the album were a significant departure from the group's previous record Definitely Maybe. Gallagher's compositions were more focused in balladry and placed more emphasis on huge choruses,[1] with the string arrangements and more varied instrumentation on the record contrasting with the rawness of the group's debut album. (What's the Story) Morning Glory? was the group's first album with drummer Alan White, who replaced Tony McCarroll.

The record propelled Oasis from being a crossover indie act to a worldwide rock phenomenon, and according to various critics, was a significant record in the timeline of British indie music.[2] The band's most commercially successful release, (What's the Story) Morning Glory? sold a record-breaking 347,000 copies in its first week on sale, spent 10 weeks at number one on the UK Albums Chart, and reached number four in the US Billboard 200. Singles from the album were successful in Britain, America and Australia: "Some Might Say" and "Don't Look Back in Anger" reached number one in the UK; "Champagne Supernova" and "Wonderwall" reached number one on the US Modern Rock Tracks chart; and "Wonderwall" topped the Australian and New Zealand singles charts.[3]

Although a commercial smash, the record received lukewarm reviews from mainstream music critics; many contemporary reviewers deemed it inferior to Definitely Maybe, with the songwriting and production particular points of criticism. In the ensuing years, however, critical opinion towards the album reversed, and it is now generally considered a seminal record of both the Britpop era, and the 1990s in general. Over several months in 1995 and 1996, the band performed an extensive world tour in support of the album. The most notable of the concerts were two Knebworth House performances in August to a combined crowd of 250,000 people. At the 1996Brit Awards, the album won Best British Album.

At the 2010 Brit Awards, (What's the Story) Morning Glory? was named the greatest British album since 1980.[4] It has sold over 16 million copies worldwide,[5] and appears on several lists of the greatest albums in rock music.
 
Easy one this. What's the Story Morning Glory is of it's time, and was obviously massive, but it's a really patchy album and Oasis were already beginning to run out of ideas. Blue Lines is probably my favourite album of the 32 in the first round and still sounds fresh today. It is timeless and it's influence was wider and lasted longer (and inspired far better bands) than WTSMG.
 
Both albums probably make my 20 most listened to albums in the 90s, but in the case of Oasis I only listen to individual songs these days and very few of them from this effort.

Love the first three MA albums. Trying my best to pretend the later ones don't exist.
 
Massive attack for me. Hugely influential and I still listen to it now. I might listen to one or two off of Wtsmg. Not oasis in their finest hour
 
Easy one this. What's the Story Morning Glory is of it's time, and was obviously massive, but it's a really patchy album and Oasis were already beginning to run out of ideas. Blue Lines is probably my favourite album of the 32 in the first round and still sounds fresh today. It is timeless and it's influence was wider and lasted longer (and inspired far better bands) than WTSMG.
Blue Lines isn't really my thing but you're absolutely right about the overall quality of WTSMG. There's some good tracks in there (in an Oasis kind of way), but there's a lot of crap too.

If anyone ever wanted to study why second albums are so difficult and the effect they have on a band's sound WTSMG is perfect.

Blue Lines is the better album even if I'd probably be more likely to listen to WTSMG, albeit with my finger on the skip button.
 
i've listened to What's the story many many times, Oasis really pulled in me in, I didn't really listen to anything other than metal at that time

it's the time when Noel Gallagher's writing was at it's peak with Oasis in my opinion, it's just that most of his best tracks were merely b-sides on single releases, the like's of Rockin Chair, Round Are Way, Acquiesce, The Swamp Song, Talk Tonight and The Masterplan would have been enough of an album for many other bands
 
i've listened to What's the story many many times, Oasis really pulled in me in, I didn't really listen to anything other than metal at that time

it's the time when Noel Gallagher's writing was at it's peak with Oasis in my opinion, it's just that most of his best tracks were merely b-sides on single releases, the like's of Rockin Chair, Round Are Way, Acquiesce, The Swamp Song, Talk Tonight and The Masterplan would have been enough of an album for many other bands

It's a shame that they didn't make the album in place of Roll With It, Some Might Say, She's Electric and Cast No Shadow.

Oasis's first two albums would both have been improved by including the better b-sides from the singles in place of the filler. But that's what a gargantuan coke habit will do to your quality control.
 
Difficult one, Oasis brings back some great personal memories around the time this album dropped, but definitely not as strong as DM. I've listed to it more than Blue Lines as well, but in a shoot-out for best album of the 90's between the two, has to be the latter.
 
i've listened to What's the story many many times, Oasis really pulled in me in, I didn't really listen to anything other than metal at that time

it's the time when Noel Gallagher's writing was at it's peak with Oasis in my opinion, it's just that most of his best tracks were merely b-sides on single releases, the like's of Rockin Chair, Round Are Way, Acquiesce, The Swamp Song, Talk Tonight and The Masterplan would have been enough of an album for many other bands
Their only album that runs Definitely Maybe even close is their B side album.
 
Blue lines all day

But I'd have been interested to see blue lines vs leftism

Also, I think leftism should be through to the next round....but I might have made that clear in other threads..... :)
 
Yay. Massive Attack go through to the next round, Oasis go home to count their billions.
 
Yay. Massive Attack go through to the next round, Oasis go home to count their billions.
I assume that Definitely Maybe is on the list somewhere. I would expect that to perform better (although still go out to a proper album)
 
I assume that Definitely Maybe is on the list somewhere. I would expect that to perform better (although still go out to a proper album)

Yes. It's in the last heat of the round but knowing the taste of many on here, I would say that they got a tough draw.
 
Back