• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Mauricio Pochettino

My point is how it compared to the squad Poch took over in summer 2014.

I bet if you listed both United's squad now and Poch's first Spurs squad after the close of the summer 2014 window (when we had the likes of Fazio, Stambouli etc), i don't think you'll be seeing much difference overall in quality.
Those players that didn’t really play for us or were bit part pkayers
They are no worse than what United have now as their squad players
But hey… some people rate the United playera
I don’t And think it’s why they have struggled again this year
They don’t have anyone who actually runs
They don’t have many very good with the ball
And let’s be honest they are a very slow side
This is all about who they have brought and who they haven’t managed to sell
 
Agree with pretty much all of this. However, I do believe that United and their fan base are one of the more patient clubs in the league. While it takes time for Poch to embed his expectations, style and culture it usually starts to happen after months rather than years. He'll get that time.

Poch plays good football, gives youth a chance and can build a football club. He's perfect for Man U IMO. The danger for him is that the toxicity around the place and the rubbish leadership above him mean it's impossible for one man to make a difference.
Were patient
They aren’t know because they have suffered from awful owners for some time and even more so now with the fake ownership set up
This is a club that is heavily heavily in debt
Has brought consistently at high prices but got generally bad value
 
Last edited:
We’re patient
They aren’t know because they have suffered from awful owners for some time and even more so now with the fake ownership set up
This is a club that is heavily heavily in debt
Has brought consistently at high prices but got generally bad value
They showed Carrick a lot of support even towards the end and I don't recall them really turning on their managers. Poch will get time there.

He got time at Chelsea after a poor start and they're a basket case when it comes to managers.
 
They showed Carrick a lot of support even towards the end and I don't recall them really turning on their managers. Poch will get time there.

He got time at Chelsea after a poor start and they're a basket case when it comes to managers.
They don’t turn on managers
They have turned on the decision makers
And they are right too
Although it does seem on anti social media that they aren’t all behind Poch
 
Uniteds squad is awful
One CF and a player in zirkee they want rid because they realised he can’t really keep up with the pace of the prem
And aging defence with Yoro and the ex arsenal kid to help keep the age down
A miss mash of centre midfielders who have no cohesive style between them
An average keeper who doesn’t excel at anything statistically or to the eye
MBuemo and Cunha are quality players and Fernandes can be …
As I said above this is the core of the team that just finished above anges side when he got fired

The side that finished 16th was first season Amorim who took over mid way through from Ten Hag when he preferred to come in the summer, because he knew his methods were such that they were not easy to implement once the season was underway. Amorim is rigid in his system and that’s on him, but I don’t think it’s true to say even that season that United were actually 16th placed quality as a squad. They were adjusting to a system they didn’t really have the players for, but by the next year Amorim had them back in the top 6 before he decided to blow it up.

I think United have some quality that Poch can do perfectly well with, and improve upon the 1 win in 10 record they have before getting to January.

I really do think Spurs and United have been through a similar thing in the last couple of years. Lots of change, which ultimately takes out the cohesion of the team and ultimately destroys the confidence of the squad. Especially because it’s two clubs whose fans have much higher expectations of the players, and where every set back is magnified further. I read so many fans of other clubs saying Spurs have terrible players and Frank had an impossible job, and I don’t think that’s the case. We were better than we showed. And I think United are better than their showing right now. They just need to get back on a good path rather than the constantly cycle of negativity they’re in right now.

To be clear, I’m not saying United’s players are world beaters. They need major surgery to get to where they want to be. But do I think Poch has enough to work with until Jan to start getting results on the board? Absolutely.
 
Agree with pretty much all of this. However, I do believe that United and their fan base are one of the more patient clubs in the league. While it takes time for Poch to embed his expectations, style and culture it usually starts to happen after months rather than years. He'll get that time.

Poch plays good football, gives youth a chance and can build a football club. He's perfect for Man U IMO. The danger for him is that the toxicity around the place and the rubbish leadership above him mean it's impossible for one man to make a difference.

Yeah I also think his DNA as a manager is perfect for them to be honest, and I think he will get time. And really I have no doubt he will be successful there. Ratcliffe being a terrible owner is the only thing that gives me a little pause. But I think he’ll do well and I’ll be gutted to see it happening with someone else, but happy for him because he deserves it.
 
Yeah I also think his DNA as a manager is perfect for them to be honest, and I think he will get time. And really I have no doubt he will be successful there. Ratcliffe being a terrible owner is the only thing that gives me a little pause. But I think he’ll do well and I’ll be gutted to see it happening with someone else, but happy for him because he deserves it.
For United
Success is winning the big trophies
Poch has never done that
What makes you think he can and will and how will they bankroll the 8/10 players he needs
I mean they need a whole new defence including a keeper
2/3 more attackers of a better standard to compliment cunha and Mbuembo
And they have to work out something for that midfield
 
For United
Success is winning the big trophies
Poch has never done that
What makes you think he can and will and how will they bankroll the 8/10 players he needs
I mean they need a whole new defence including a keeper
2/3 more attackers of a better standard to compliment cunha and Mbuembo
And they have to work out something for that midfield

Poch got Tottenham under the constraints of Levy to two genuine title challenges, including an 86 point season, and a CL final on a Winks / Sissoko pivot,

I see no reason why given time he couldn’t win trophies with them. I don’t think there’s some fundamental failing he has that means he’s incapable, I think he’s more than capable. I do think top managers have a swagger and a confidence that transmits to the players and means they get it done in the biggest games (I include Ange in this aspect) so maybe that’s a question on Poch but…not really? I think he’s has enough aura and motivational capability to get it done and for the players to buy in, and I think he and United compliment each other very well.

Their whole DNA is built upon trusting in young players to establish a culture, and to compliment that with top talent. They believe in culture, and the fans believe in the patience and the time to establish it because they saw it worked with Fergie. Poch is the most Fergie-like manager in the modern era in my view, because what he was doing with us was a modern version of what Fergie did. He’s the perfect spiritual successor.
 
Poch got Tottenham under the constraints of Levy to two genuine title challenges, including an 86 point season, and a CL final on a Winks / Sissoko pivot,

I see no reason why given time he couldn’t win trophies with them. I don’t think there’s some fundamental failing he has that means he’s incapable, I think he’s more than capable. I do think top managers have a swagger and a confidence that transmits to the players and means they get it done in the biggest games (I include Ange in this aspect) so maybe that’s a question on Poch but…not really? I think he’s has enough aura and motivational capability to get it done and for the players to buy in, and I think he and United compliment each other very well.

Their whole DNA is built upon trusting in young players to establish a culture, and to compliment that with top talent. They believe in culture, and the fans believe in the patience and the time to establish it because they saw it worked with Fergie. Poch is the most Fergie-like manager in the modern era in my view, because what he was doing with us was a modern version of what Fergie did. He’s the perfect spiritual successor.
Poch had Kane
Poch at no point had to find a 30 goal a season striker which saved him and the club a LOT of focus and effort
He also got in Sonny later
Dele early
United would need to find some amazing players as their top youth are either leaving or actually not that good yet
If they give Poch the 4 years fergie had with no trophies I’d be stunned because that massive affects their revenue and income
 
Poch had Kane
Poch at no point had to find a 30 goal a season striker which saved him and the club a LOT of focus and effort
He also got in Sonny later
Dele early
United would need to find some amazing players as their top youth are either leaving or actually not that good yet
If they give Poch the 4 years fergie had with no trophies I’d be stunned because that massive affects their revenue and income
Element of truth in what you're saying but if anyone would have said when Poch got the job that he'd be relying on Kane, a kid from MK Dons and a South Korean, you wouldn't have dreamed we'd be anywhere near as good as we were.

There may be a lot of untapped talent hiding at Old Trafford and if there is, Poch has a good chance of finding it.
 
Poch had Kane
Poch at no point had to find a 30 goal a season striker which saved him and the club a LOT of focus and effort
He also got in Sonny later
Dele early
United would need to find some amazing players as their top youth are either leaving or actually not that good yet
If they give Poch the 4 years fergie had with no trophies I’d be stunned because that massive affects their revenue and income

When Poch joined us we didn't mention Kane as an asset that would really make his time work; Kane was someone Poch eventually used and helped develop into the start he is now.
Who knows if Poch will do the same for the likes of Lacey, or even their CB Heaven.

The way Sonny and Dele developed is testament to what Poch can do and again it would be a big assumption to think this Man Utd squad (who let's not forget finished 3rd last season) couldn't be elevated by Poch in a similar way he did us.
We hadn't finished in the top 4 for a few years before Poch came, whilst United did in the last year. So that shows what can be possible if coaching/luck/timing come together for them..
 
Element of truth in what you're saying but if anyone would have said when Poch got the job that he'd be relying on Kane, a kid from MK Dons and a South Korean, you wouldn't have dreamed we'd be anywhere near as good as we were.

There may be a lot of untapped talent hiding at Old Trafford and if there is, Poch has a good chance of finding it.
Not at all
But he kept the job because he inherited the best striker on the planet
If we as a club were trying to buy a striker of kanes level …. We wouldn’t have been at the races
 
When Poch joined us we didn't mention Kane as an asset that would really make his time work; Kane was someone Poch eventually used and helped develop into the start he is now.
Who knows if Poch will do the same for the likes of Lacey, or even their CB Heaven.

The way Sonny and Dele developed is testament to what Poch can do and again it would be a big assumption to think this Man Utd squad (who let's not forget finished 3rd last season) couldn't be elevated by Poch in a similar way he did us.
We hadn't finished in the top 4 for a few years before Poch came, whilst United did in the last year. So that shows what can be possible if coaching/luck/timing come together for them..
3rd last season with NO extra games and a very lucky run …. Their form was the best in the league and they are nowhere near that good
They were 16th the year before
And see comment above
Poch was getting the sack at spurs
The Kane free kick saved him (his thoughts not mine)
And Kane went on from strength to strength which meant goals were not an issue
United do not have goals in them in that squad
Their only CF is injured but IMO is a very good prospects and player if they can get him fit
Heaven or Lacey will need to step up massively. Kane did it cause it’s Kane. The vast majority of why Kane has made it is because of him not his coaches IMO… he works harder than any player to get better
We will see very soon what he does there
 
3rd last season with NO extra games and a very lucky run …. Their form was the best in the league and they are nowhere near that good
They were 16th the year before
And see comment above
Poch was getting the sack at spurs
The Kane free kick saved him (his thoughts not mine)
And Kane went on from strength to strength which meant goals were not an issue
United do not have goals in them in that squad
Their only CF is injured but IMO is a very good prospects and player if they can get him fit
Heaven or Lacey will need to step up massively. Kane did it cause it’s Kane. The vast majority of why Kane has made it is because of him not his coaches IMO… he works harder than any player to get better
We will see very soon what he does there

Ok.

In your opinion, who will finish us or Man Utd?
 
I wanna be clear here
I live Poch for what happened here
It was the most enjoyable period of watching spurs in my life
What he managed to do was get unity within the club form top to bottom and that have him the freedom to do what he did
He was the club for that period
I was gutted when they sacked him
He has earned the right to stay by some way
But I get 100% why the club did it
 
Poch had Kane
Poch at no point had to find a 30 goal a season striker which saved him and the club a LOT of focus and effort
He also got in Sonny later
Dele early
United would need to find some amazing players as their top youth are either leaving or actually not that good yet
If they give Poch the 4 years fergie had with no trophies I’d be stunned because that massive affects their revenue and income

100%

Kane is the best striker of his generation in the world, United aren't going to uncover one of those somewhere.
Son is arguably one of the better wingers in the PL who was two footed, made a partnership with said generational striker and outperformed his xG for his entire career.
Walker, best English RB of his generation
Lloris in his prime
Jan/Toby, defenders that conceded 26 goals in an entire season?
Dembele a unique CM that was almost impossible to dispossess

Poch is not re-creating that with United, not saying he couldn't have them in/around European places, but their debt requires CL football regularly, and they have one of the issues we had for a long time, they can't sell for brick. Rashford, Shaw, Maguire, Dalot, Mount, Ugarte, Zirkzee all need to be sold.
 
I wanna be clear here
I live Poch for what happened here
It was the most enjoyable period of watching spurs in my life
What he managed to do was get unity within the club form top to bottom and that have him the freedom to do what he did
He was the club for that period
I was gutted when they sacked him
He has earned the right to stay by some way
But I get 100% why the club did it
This is nearly exactly what I said when he was sacked - except that I felt the unity had vanished. Something happened within the club, mostly visible by the sharp decline of Eriksen in the latter part of the previous season. He really was that important to us and the way we played. When we "lost" him, most if not all of our creative and unpredictable game fell apart. Yes Kane was one of the top 3 strikers in the world, still I maintain that we played our best football when he stayed up top being served and baiting defenders, not as the hybrid striker-winger-midfielder he had to play in his last years because we never replaced Christian. Son and Kane masked much of the fact that without Eriksen, Verthongen and a working Alli, the rest of the squad wasn't all that.
 
Back