You are right about the ifs and buts and that sums up the game all round. The point i was making is that ( imo) the signing of a better CB ( then they already have) and a better keeper will/should improve them as a team. I am not saying that it will make them title winners either, but seeing as they are one point in front of us now do you not think that IF those signing make them a better team should we not
consider that?
I think you miss the fundamental thing here.
Liverpool, as a team, are brick defensively. To the point its like they barely even try. There is no defending from the front. There is no defending from the middle! Or the sides - the fullbacks are always miles up field.
This means the defence is just fudged. No matter who is playing. Put Maldini in there in his prime, it wont make much difference because they are so badly and continually exposed.
I think VVD is a decent defender. Not great, but certainly not bad. BUT, I also think, he wont make any real difference at all.
Liverpool need to be coached in defending. How to keep shape, keep a line, what space to mark... literally the very basics. This is not something that will be fixed with a new player.
Ill predict one thing though. Typically they will keep a few clean sheets in the coming games, and VVD will get all the MOTD moments in defence, and all the pundits will be praising him from the rooftops as a steal and the answer to all their problems* but by easter we will all be sat here saying the same as the last few seasons. It doesnt matter who plays while that team has no clue how to defend.
*A lot like how Lukaku was a bargain for Utd, exactly what they needed, better than Kane etc - where is that narrative now?
Is it 100 now? I read 75 three hours ago.
Maybe thats inclusive of wages? If they paid £75m for him Im sure he is on ridiculous money each week as well...